At this point in my fishing career I am all about finding my confidence baits sticking to em while also trying to eliminate as much waste and clutter as possible. I like the idea of using baits that I know work. I also like to try and buy it in bulk because there's nothing worse than running out of a bait that is flat putting fish in boat in the middle of an outing. I usually gain confidence in a particular bait by putting it in scenarios where it has historically produced well before and having it produce yet again. Forget the new magic gimmick bait that comes out by the dozen every spring. Give me the time tested bait that I have had success with in the past and that's were I will invest my money.I guess that's why they say that experience is the best teacher. Thankfully I have a lot more than ten, but if I were limited to ten lures they would be as follows in no particular order.
1) Pearl White 5" Zoom Super Fluke Rigged on a 4/0 EWG hook. This bait is my spring time home run hitter. I have caught more fish over 3 lbs. with this fish than any other.It doesn't catch the most fish of any bait but it does catch the piggies.
2) 1/4th oz. In-line Elite Joe Fly Spinner in brown or black. This lure is the anytime anywhere lure to beat all lures. It is heavy enough to throw far, fish deep water or heavy current. I have caught fish with this lure in streams, rivers, ponds, lakes, creeks, or any other body of water where fish swim. Most impressive is that it is equally deadly for both trout and bass cut also catches redeyes, bluegills, crappie, you name it. In fact this lure is so versatile that I have caught nearly every species in our local waters and that's no exaggeration. If you could only have one lure to fish with all your life this would be it for me. It catches all species in all types of water, cold or hot water, fish big or small. This little lure is stoppable and amazingly you don't see that many people fishing with them. Sure you see a lot of small in line spinners and rooster tails, but they don't have the short striker hook, a full hair body, a bullet weight, or the body wobble to go with that flashing blade.
3) Yellow Foam Bug. AKA Bluegill Getter. For summertime top water fun with a flypole this one is an all time great. Their cheap and you don't have to worry about them losing their buoyancy and sinking like other dry flies. I have caught some really nice bonus bass in the summer on these as well.
4) White/Black/Green Pumpkin/ or Brown 3" Gitzit G-tail. And really the brand is not a must. I just think that Gitzit g-tails have that little something extra and are much more durable than other brands. Back when I fished for smallies only in rivers exclusively this was my thing. My tackle collection was G-tails with more G-tails. When the river is on this bait produces large numbers of fish. It isn't the best big fish go getter but it will occasionally land a big one. The strongest thing about this bait is that it can be fished slow or fast and shallow or deep without any modification or retying .When you are floating down the river in strong current and do not have a lot of time to change or modify a bait g-tails are a standout choice.
5) 5"Green Pumpkin Shakey Head worm. A tournament fisherman's go to bait. This bait will catch bass under the most horrible conditions. Post cold front, blue bird skies, on a highly pressured lake? No problem just get a shakey head in front their noses and they will eat it even when they won't touch anything else.I have had many a day when this lure consistently landed fish when absolutely nothing else would.
6) Black Jitterbug. In low light one night conditions, river, lake or pond this one works the bass magic like now other. They have that patented chug chug chug sound that drives bass nuts. This lure is an old classic but still very relevant weapon in today's angler arsenal. It hard to beat that feeling you get when you hear a bass go "Chur-Thump" this lure in the darkness.
7) 3" Green Pumpkin Tube Jig on 1/8oz. 2/0 tube head. When you live where the New River and Greenbrier River merge and smallmouth bass is your primary game fish you learn to love what tube jigs can do for you, especially in cold water months. Although you do hang up and lose a lot of tubes they are cheap. I can get them with a quality head from Barlow's for $0.32 a piece when you buy 100 at time. You find some slack water below a big eddy in the winter or very early spring months and put a tube in their face then hold on because it's going to be a wild ride. For years I hated using tubes despite seeing my friends catch amazing numbers of big fish on them because I hung them up so much. Despite their high attrition rate these lures have their place for catching your absolute biggest smallie of year.
8) Lucky Craft CB 12 Crank bait in Chartreuse Shad. Crankbaits like spinner bait and G-tail can be fished fast and allow you to cover very large volume of water quickly to find active fish. But unlike other search baits crankbaits go out and probe the depths. I really like how these lures allow you to fish fast and still fish deeper waters where monsters live.
9) 5" Gary Yammamoto Senko in Baby Bass. Although it may be a little past it's prime this lure at certain times is a dynamo for largemouth bass. When the fish won't chase and are relating are relating to wood, shallow drainage ditches in coves, or other hard to fish areas this lure produces. Rather you rig it weedless on a 4/0 or 5/0 hook it so easy to fish that even a kid could do it.
10) Strike King Premier Plus Double Willow blade in white and chartreuse. In stained water this one is a stand out search bait in lakes. It's V shaped design allow you to fish it through the nastiest of heavy cover and that is in fact how it is most productive.
Honorable Mention: Lucky Craft Pointer 100 in Gunmetal Shad. In the 45 to 55 degree water temps theses catch suspended bass like nothing else. But outside of that they can be out fished by other baits.
Considerable Mention: 5" Zara Spook in Bone White. Yeah I know just another topwater bait that gets hung up on every piece of cover it touches, but there is just something about this lures action that makes it both a fish magnet and fun to fish.